Choosing the right business structure is one of the most important decisions you’ll make as an entrepreneur, and one option that often comes up is the S Corporation (S Corp).
So, what is an S Corp?
Simply put, it’s a unique type of corporation that offers both tax benefits and legal protections, making it an attractive choice for many business owners.
According to the IRS, there are over 5 million S Corps filed in the U.S, with many small businesses opting for this structure because of its flexibility and financial benefits.
However, not all businesses are eligible. To become an S Corp, a company must meet specific requirements. Understanding the rules and benefits is important for businesses considering an S Corp.
In this post, we’ll answer the question, What is an S Corp? And how they compare to other business structures. We’ll also guide you through the requirements for forming an S Corp.
Disclaimer: This content contains a few affiliate links, which means we’ll earn a commission when you click on them (at no additional cost to you).
What is an S Corp?
An S Corporation, or S Corp, is a legal business entity that elects to pass corporate income, losses, deductions, and credits to its shareholders. However, this legal business must be recognized by the IRS.
One of the biggest perks of this structure is that it helps business owners avoid double taxation — where both the company and its owners are taxed separately. S Corps operate under the same rules as C Corporations but follow different tax regulations.
So, what is an S Corp best suited for? This structure is ideal for businesses looking for liability protection of a corporation but prefer the tax benefits of a partnership.
Unlike other corporations, S Corps do not pay federal income taxes directly. Instead, profits and losses pass through to shareholders, who report them on their personal tax returns. Shareholders pay taxes on their portion of the company’s earnings based on their individual tax brackets.
This tax treatment, known as pass-through taxation, is similar to partnerships and LLCs. Owners also have limited liability, protecting their personal assets from business debts and lawsuits. However, an S Corp can lose its tax status if it violates IRS rules.
Requirements and Eligibility Criteria for S Corp Status
Now that you understand what is an S Corp, it’s important to know the requirements and eligibility criteria. Not every business can elect to have an S Corp status.
The IRS has strict rules to ensure that only qualified businesses receive the tax advantages of this structure.
Here are the major eligibility requirements for an S Corp status.
- Maximum number of shareholders: An S corporation can have no more than 100 shareholders. This rule helps maintain the simplicity of the pass-through taxation system. Exceeding this limit can result in the loss of S corporation status, leading to taxation as a regular C corporation.
- Citizenship and residency restrictions: All shareholders of an S Corp must be U.S. citizens, with certain trusts and estates as owners. Non-resident aliens are not allowed to own shares. This rule exists because S Corps pass income directly to shareholders, and collecting taxes from foreign owners can be challenging.
- Permitted business structures: An S Corp must first be a domestic corporation. It cannot be an LLC, partnership, or sole proprietorship. However, an LLC can be taxed as an S Corp if it meets IRS requirements. Businesses like certain financial institutions and insurance companies cannot be S Corps. These industries have complex tax rules that conflict with S Corp taxation.
- Stock classification rules: This is another critical aspect of S corporation eligibility. An S Corp can only issue one class of stock, and all shares must have equal rights to profits and losses. S Corps cannot offer preferred stock with special benefits. This rule ensures fairness among shareholders.
How Does an S Corp Work?
We’ve answered the question, What is an S Corp? Now let’s discuss how it works. An S Corporation (S Corp) blends the benefits of a small business corporation with tax advantages for its owners. It follows specific rules under the IRS to avoid double taxation.
Here’s how it works:
Operational Structure
An S Corp operates like a traditional corporation but with a few differences. So, what is an S Corp operational structure?
It is a separate legal entity, meaning it can own assets, sign contracts, and be held liable for debts. The business must follow corporate formalities, including holding regular board meetings and keeping records of major decisions.
S Corps must have a board of directors that oversees major policies and decisions. Meanwhile, officers like the CEO or president handle day-to-day operations. The structure ensures accountability and proper management while limiting owner liability.
Role of Shareholders and Management
In an S Corp structure, the shareholders own the company but are not responsible for managing daily business activities. Instead, they elect directors who set company policies and oversee the management team.
The management team, which is often made up of corporate officers, is responsible for handling the corporation’s daily operations. The president or CEO runs the business, while other officers oversee finances, marketing, and other key areas. In smaller S Corps, shareholders may also act as officers or employees.
Taxation
Unlike traditional C Corporations, which face double taxation (at both the corporate and individual level), an S Corp’s profits and losses pass directly to shareholders.
Each shareholder reports their share of the company’s income, losses, deductions, and credits on their personal tax return. With the S Corp structure, the business itself is exempt from paying federal corporate income tax, preventing taxation at both the company and shareholder levels.
However, the shareholder’s salaries are subject to income taxes. The IRS outlines the tax obligations of S Corp shareholders and the appropriate forms available for filing these taxes.
Image via IRS
Any additional income they earn from the S Corp, such as dividends, is not subject to self-employment taxes.
What is an S Corp: Benefits and Challenges
Business owners need to understand what is an S Corp, the benefits, and the challenges of this structure before deciding if it’s the right choice for their needs.
Here are the major benefits and challenges of choosing an S Corp.
Benefits of Electing an S Corp
1. Pass-Through Taxation
S Corporations do not pay federal income taxes at the corporate level. Instead, profits and losses pass through to shareholders, who report them on their individual tax returns.
Business owners often opt for the S Corp because individual tax rates are often lower than corporate tax rates. This pass-through taxation structure can lead to significant tax savings, especially for small businesses. It also allows owners to offset business losses against other personal income.
2. Limited Liability Protection
An S Corp shields its owners from personal liability. This means shareholders’ personal assets, such as homes or cars, are protected if the business faces lawsuits or debts.
If the company gets sued or goes into debt, creditors cannot pursue personal assets to recover losses. This protection gives business owners peace of mind, knowing their personal assets remain separate from the company’s risks.
However, limited liability protection is not absolute. If owners fail to maintain corporate formalities, mix personal and business finances, or commit fraud, they could lose this protection.
Courts may hold them personally responsible under a legal concept called “piercing the corporate veil.” This makes it essential for S Corp owners to follow legal requirements strictly.
3. Self-Employment Tax Savings
Shareholders who work for the company can be considered employees and receive salaries. This allows them to avoid paying self-employment tax on the entire business income.
Instead, they pay payroll taxes on their salary, lowering the tax rate on any additional profits. Doing so can significantly reduce tax burdens compared to sole proprietorships or partnerships.
However, the IRS requires that shareholder-employees receive “reasonable compensation” for their work. They cannot take all business earnings as distributions to avoid payroll taxes.
The IRS may audit businesses that attempt to underpay salaries and take excessive profits as tax-free distributions. Proper payroll management ensures compliance while maximizing tax savings.
4. Increased Credibility
Operating as an S Corporation can improve a company’s credibility with customers, suppliers, and financial institutions. Many lenders prefer to work with incorporated businesses rather than sole proprietors or partnerships.
Investors and potential business partners often view S Corporations as stable and structured entities. This credibility can lead to more business opportunities, better financing options, and stronger stakeholder relationships.
Additionally, customers may feel more confident dealing with a legally recognized corporation.
5. Easier Transfer of Ownership
S Corporations allow for a smoother transfer of ownership compared to other business structures. Shares can be easily sold or transferred without disrupting business operations.
An S Corporation’s structure makes it easier to plan for succession, ensuring business continuity in the event of retirement or unforeseen circumstances.
Unlike LLCs, which may require dissolution if the owner(s) exit the business — in the case of a single member or multi-member LLC — you don’t need to dissolve an S Corporation in the event of the death of any of the owners.
6. Attracting and Retaining Employees
S Corporations can offer competitive employee benefits, making it easier for businesses to attract and retain top talent. Unlike sole proprietorships and partnerships, S Corporations can provide tax-advantaged benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, and stock options.
Employees value these benefits, which can improve job satisfaction and reduce turnover. Additionally, offering equity in the form of stock incentives can align employee interests with the company’s success.
Common Challenges and Drawbacks of Electing an S Corp
While S corporations provide many advantages, they also have certain restrictions and responsibilities. You should consider these drawbacks and the S Corp checklist before opting for this business structure.
Below are five common challenges S Corporations often encounter:
1. Strict Ownership Rules
Not all businesses qualify to become an S Corp. The IRS has strict rules on ownership to limit who can benefit from this structure. An S Corp can have no more than 100 shareholders.
This rule prevents large corporations from using S Corp status for tax advantages meant for smaller businesses.
Additionally, all shareholders must be U.S. citizens or residents. Only individuals, certain trusts, and estates can own shares. Other corporations or partnerships cannot be shareholders. These rules help ensure that S Corps remain small and closely held businesses.
2. Increased IRS Scrutiny on Salary vs. Distributions
The IRS closely monitors how S Corporation owners classify their income. Since only salaries (not distributions) are subject to Social Security and Medicare taxes, some business owners may attempt to minimize their salary and maximize their distributions to reduce tax liability.
However, the IRS requires that owners take a “reasonable” salary based on industry standards. Failing to do so can result in audits, penalties, and tax adjustments, making compliance essential for S Corp owners.
3. State-Level Taxation Complexities
Understanding what is an S Corp and the tax complexities is crucial before deciding on this business structure. While S Corporations benefit from federal pass-through taxation, state taxation rules vary. Some states do not recognize S Corp status, requiring these businesses to pay corporate taxes at the state level.
Other states impose franchise taxes or additional fees on S Corps. Managing these varying tax laws can be complex and may reduce the overall tax benefits of an S Corp in certain states.
4. Compliance and Administrative Burdens
Operating as an S Corporation comes with ongoing compliance requirements. Business owners must maintain corporate records, file annual reports, hold shareholder meetings, and follow strict operational procedures.
These administrative responsibilities can be time-consuming and require the help of legal services, thereby increasing business costs.
5. Potential Limitations on Growth and Investment
S Corporations may face challenges when seeking outside investment. Unlike C Corporations, which can issue multiple classes of stock to attract investors, S Corps are limited to a single class of stock.
This restriction makes it harder to offer flexible equity arrangements, which may deter venture capitalists or institutional investors.
Additionally, foreign investors cannot hold shares in an S Corp, further limiting opportunities for global expansion.
Steps to Elect an S Corporation
Forming an S corporation can impact your business’s tax structure and liability protection. It’s not enough to know what is an S Corp, you need to understand the specific requirements and procedures involved before making the switch.
Here are the key steps to file to become an S Corporation:
1. Decide on the State For Incorporation
Each state has its own set of rules and requirements for forming an S corporation. Even the forms and filing fees differ from state to state. Some states, like Delaware, Nevada, and Wyoming, are known for their incorporation-friendly policies. Similarly, Texas, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and others offer attractive options for forming an S corp.
Many entrepreneurs incorporate their S Corp in their home state because of convenience and familiarity with local laws. However, choosing the right state for incorporation involves more than just proximity.
You need to consider factors such as state income tax, franchise tax, and regulatory requirements. Some states impose high annual fees and strict compliance rules, which can increase operating costs.
2. Choose a Business Name and Register It
Your business name must follow state naming rules. It should be unique and not conflict with existing business names. Check availability through your state’s business database before registering. Once approved, register the name with your state’s Secretary of State office.
After registration, consider securing a domain name matching your business name. This will help with branding and online presence. You may also need a Doing Business As (DBA) name if you operate under a different name. Check local and state regulations to ensure compliance.
3. Appoint a Registered Agent
You’ll need a registered agent for both non-profit and for-profit business entities. This agent receives legal documents on behalf of your business. They must have a physical address in the state where your S Corporation is formed to ensure you receive important legal notices.
A registered agent can be an individual or a company if they meet the requirements. Many businesses choose a professional registered agent service because they offer consistent availability and privacy. This service helps your business handle legal correspondence efficiently.
4. File Articles of Incorporation
The articles of incorporation formally establish your corporation with the state, similar to the articles of organization for an LLC. This document typically includes essential information such as the business name, purpose, registered agent, and authorized shares. Filing these articles with the appropriate state agency is a mandatory legal requirement.
Carefully review your state’s specific requirements for filing articles of incorporation, as they can vary. Providing accurate and complete information is crucial to prevent delays or the rejection of your filing. Once your filing is approved, the state will issue a certificate of incorporation, officially recognizing your business as a legal entity.
Business formation service providers such as Tailor Brands, Inc Authority, ZenBusiness, and LegalZoom offer expert assistance filing business documents. Some of these companies can also handle the S-Corp election process for you.
5. Apply for an EIN (Employer Identification Number)
An EIN for an S Corp, similar to a social security number for individuals, is required for tax purposes. You can obtain a tax ID for free from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) website. Alternatively, you can apply by mail or fax using Form SS-4. This tax ID number is essential for filing necessary taxes.
The online EIN application process is straightforward and typically takes only a few minutes. Ensure you have your business’s legal name, address, and the names of its responsible parties readily available. The IRS uses the tax ID number to track your business’s tax obligations and ensure compliance.
6. Set Up Corporate Bylaws And Issue Stock
Corporate bylaws are the internal rules that govern the operation of your corporation. They outline the roles and responsibilities of directors and officers, meeting procedures, and other essential aspects of corporate governance. While bylaws aren’t always required for filing, they are essential for maintaining a well-organized internal structure.
Issuing stock to shareholders is another fundamental step in establishing your S Corporation. This process involves determining the number of authorized shares and distributing them among the S Corp owners. Stock certificates serve as proof of ownership and should be properly documented.
7. Elect S Corporation status with the IRS
To elect S Corporation status, you must file Form 2553 with the IRS. This form is used to notify the IRS of your election status. You must meet specific eligibility requirements.
Understanding what is an S Corp is key here. It is a tax election, not a business entity. This form must be submitted within 75 days of forming your corporation or at the start of a tax year. You may have to wait until the following year if you miss the deadline. You need all shareholders to sign it before submission.
8. Obtain Necessary Licenses and Permits
Depending on your industry and location, you may need to obtain various licenses and permits to operate legally. These can include general business and professional licenses and permits related to specific activities. Contact appropriate government agencies to determine the required licenses.
Operating without the necessary licenses and permits can result in fines and legal penalties. Ensure you regularly update records of all licenses and permits and renew them as required. Compliance with these regulations is essential for maintaining your business’s good standing.
9. Open a Business Bank Account
Separating your personal and business finances is essential for maintaining accurate records and protecting your personal assets. For your S Corp, you can open a dedicated business bank account using your EIN and articles of incorporation. This account will be used for all business transactions.
Having a dedicated business bank account simplifies bookkeeping and tax preparation. It also enhances your business’s credibility and professionalism. Choose a bank that offers services and features that meet your business’s specific needs, such as online banking, business credit cards, and merchant services.
10. Comply with ongoing state requirements
S Corporations must comply with ongoing state requirements to maintain their legal standing. These include filing annual reports, paying necessary fees, and keeping proper corporate records. Each state has different deadlines and specific requirements, so staying informed is essential.
Additionally, S Corporations must follow rules such as holding annual meetings and maintaining detailed minutes of shareholder and director meetings. Proper record-keeping is crucial for audits and tax filings. Some states require S Corporations to submit periodic statements or financial disclosures.
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Filing for an S Corp
Knowing what is an S Corp is not enough to get you through the process of electing one. You’ll be faced with several steps and might make some mistakes if you’re not careful.
To help set you on the right path, here are some common mistakes you should avoid making:
1. Missing the Filing Deadline
One of the biggest mistakes businesses make is missing the IRS deadline for the S Corp election. To take advantage of the tax benefits, you must submit Form 2553 within two months and 15 days of the start of the tax year. Missing the deadline means your election won’t be effective until the following year.
So mark the deadline on your calendar and set reminders to ensure you file on time. You can request late election relief under IRS guidelines if you miss it, but approval isn’t guaranteed.
2. Having an Ineligible Shareholder
S Corps have strict limitations on who can own shares. If a corporation, partnership, church-controlled organization, or non-resident alien owns shares, the S Corp status can be revoked. This can lead to unexpected tax liabilities and legal complications.
Hence, it’s important to monitor shareholder qualifications closely. If ownership changes, verify that new shareholders meet IRS rules before transferring stock.
3. Mixing Personal and Business Finances
If you don’t separate your business and personal finances, you risk losing the liability protection S Corps offer.
If you use business funds for personal expenses, the IRS may disregard your corporate structure, leading to tax penalties and personal liability for business debts.
To avoid this, open a dedicated business bank account and use separate credit cards for business transactions. Maintain clear financial records and avoid using company funds for personal expenses.
4. Failing to Keep Proper Corporate Records
Although the S Corps avoids double taxation, it must follow corporate formalities. Failing to maintain accurate records, such as meeting minutes and shareholder agreements, can lead to legal issues and loss of liability protection.
You are required to hold regular board meetings, document decisions in meeting minutes, and maintain financial records in compliance with state and federal laws.
5. Ignoring State Tax and Compliance Requirements
While an S Corp is a federal tax designation, states have their own tax rules and compliance requirements. Some states do not recognize S Corps, while others impose additional taxes, such as franchise or state payroll taxes.
Ignoring these requirements can lead to unexpected tax bills and penalties. Research state-specific S Corp rules and ensure compliance with all state filing and tax obligations.
S Corp vs. Other Business Structures
Choosing the right business structure affects taxes, liability, and management. An S Corporation (S Corp) offers unique advantages but has restrictions. How does it compare to structures like C Corporations (C Corps) and Limited Liability Companies (LLCs)? Let’s find out.
S Corporation vs. C Corporation
| Feature | S Corp | C Corp |
| Taxation | Pass-through taxation; no corporate income tax. Profits/losses pass to shareholders. | Double taxation: Corporations pay taxes on profits, and Shareholders pay taxes on dividends. |
| Ownership | Limited to 100 shareholders, all must be U.S. citizens or residents. | No limit on shareholders; can include foreign investors. |
| Stock Type | One class of stock allowed. | Can issue multiple classes of stock. |
| Liability Protection | Limited liability for owners. | Limited liability for owners. |
| Management | Structured like a corporation with directors and officers. | Requires a board of directors, officers, and formal corporate governance. |
| Business Suitability | Best for small to mid-sized businesses looking for tax advantages. | Suitable for large businesses seeking to raise capital from investors. |
S Corps avoid double taxation, making them attractive for small businesses. However, they have ownership restrictions and must follow corporate formalities. C Corps offers more flexibility in raising capital, but it comes with higher tax burdens.
S Corporation vs. Limited Liability Company
| Feature | S Corp | LLC |
| Taxation | Pass-through taxation avoids corporate tax but requires owners to pay self-employment tax. | Pass-through taxation is by default; you can elect corporate taxation. |
| Ownership | Limited to 100 U.S. shareholders. | No limit on members; can have foreign owners. |
| Management | Managed by directors and officers. | Flexible management; can be member-managed or manager-managed. |
| Liability Protection | Owners protected from business debts. | Owners protected from business debts. |
| Business Suitability | Best for small businesses with stable income wanting tax benefits. | Ideal for businesses needing flexibility in ownership and management. |
LLCs offer simplicity in management and ownership, making them popular with small business owners. S Corps provide tax benefits but require more formal structure and restrictions. Businesses with steady profits may benefit from S Corp tax savings, while those needing ownership flexibility may prefer an LLC.
Converting to or From an S Corp
Switching to or from an S Corp requires careful planning. You need to understand the process and implications to help you make informed decisions.
Steps to switch from an LLC or C Corp to an S Corp
Switching from a C Corp or LLC to an S Corp can provide tax savings, especially for businesses seeking to avoid double taxation. Here are the key steps:
- Ensure Eligibility: Confirm that your business qualifies for S Corp status. The IRS requires that the company has 100 or fewer shareholders, all of whom must be U.S. citizens or residents. It also cannot be owned by partnerships, other corporations, or non-resident aliens.
- File IRS Form 2553: Submit Form 2553, “Election by a Small Business Corporation,” to the IRS. All shareholders or members must sign the form. The deadline for filing is two months and 15 days after the start of the tax year for which the election applies.
- Update State Registration: Some states require additional filings to recognize S Corp status. Check with your state’s business registration office to ensure compliance.
- Adjust Operating Agreements and Bylaws: When transitioning from an LLC, update the operating agreement to reflect S Corp taxation. When moving from a C Corp, update bylaws to ensure compliance with IRS restrictions.
- Modify Payroll and Taxes: S Corps must pay owners a reasonable salary, with payroll taxes deducted. Owners can take additional profits as distributions, which are not subject to self-employment taxes.
How to Move from an S Corp to an LLC or C Corp
Sometimes, an S Corp no longer aligns with a business’s needs. If that’s the case, transitioning back to an LLC or C Corp involves the following steps:
- Revoke S Corp Election: File a written statement with the IRS to revoke S Corp status. All shareholders must consent to the revocation.
- Change Business Structure with the State: If converting to an LLC, file S Corp dissolution paperwork for the corporation and create a new LLC. For a C Corp, simply revoke S Corp status and continue operations.
- Adjust Tax Filings: Notify the IRS of the structural change and prepare for different tax treatment. A C Corp pays corporate taxes, while an LLC returns to pass-through taxation.
- Modify Ownership and Bylaws: If switching to an LLC, dissolve the corporate structure and distribute assets accordingly. If reverting to a C Corp, remove S Corp-specific shareholder restrictions.
- Review Financial and Legal Implications: Work with an accountant and attorney to ensure compliance with federal and state laws.
FAQ
1. What is an S Corp, and how does it differ from other business structures?
An S Corporation (S Corp) is a special type of corporation that offers pass-through taxation. This means the business itself does not pay income taxes at the corporate level. Unlike a C Corporation, which faces double taxation (corporate taxes plus personal income taxes on dividends), an S Corp avoids this by being taxed only at its shareholders’ individual income tax rates.
2. How does a small business corporation pay income taxes?
Small business corporations pay corporate income tax on their profits. The company files a federal tax return separate from its owners. If the business is structured as a C corporation, it pays taxes at the corporate income tax rate. If it’s an S corporation, profits pass through to the shareholders’ personal tax returns, and they pay personal income tax on their share.
3. What businesses should consider electing an S Corp status?
Small businesses looking to reduce tax liability and protect owners from personal liability should consider an S Corp. However, not all businesses qualify. To elect S Corp status, a company must:
- Be a domestic business
- Have 100 or fewer shareholders
- Issue only one class of stock
- Have eligible shareholders (U.S. citizens, residents, or certain trusts)
Professional service businesses, such as law firms, medical practices, and consulting firms, can benefit from S Corp status.
4. Are there any benefits of electing an S Corp?
Yes. Electing an S Corp offers several advantages:
- Pass-Through Taxation: Avoids corporate taxes, reducing overall tax liability.
- Limited Liability Protection: Protects personal assets from business debts.
- Salary and Dividend Options: Owners can take income as a mix of salary and distributions, lowering self-employment taxes.
- Increased Credibility: Some customers and investors see corporations as more legitimate than sole proprietorships or partnerships.
5. What is the difference between an LLC and an S Corp?
An LLC (Limited Liability Company) is a flexible business structure that protects owners from personal liability. It allows pass-through taxation, but profits are subject to self-employment taxes.
An S Corp is a tax designation, not a business entity. It helps reduce self-employment taxes by allowing owners to take a portion of their income as distributions.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right business structure is a critical decision that impacts taxes, legal liability, and overall business operations.
We’ve answered the question, “What is an S Corp?” and explored the benefits of electing S Corporation status, including pass-through taxation, limited liability protection, and potential savings on self-employment taxes.
These benefits make it a popular choice for small to mid-sized businesses looking to optimize their tax strategy while maintaining corporate protections. However, electing S Corp status requires strict eligibility requirements and operational formalities.
Before deciding on an S Corp election, carefully weigh the pros and cons. While the tax advantages can be significant, some businesses may find the administrative requirements and restrictions too limiting.
Consulting with a tax professional or legal service is highly recommended if you’re considering forming an S Corp or converting your existing business.